First meeting: Oct. 26, 1979 - Evergreen 13, Shelton 7
Latest meeting: Oct. 10, 2024 - Evergreen 39, Shelton 5
Next meeting: 2025
Meetings total: 5
All-time series: Evergreen Leads 5-0
League series: Evergreen Leads 5-0
Post-season series: n/a
Largest victory: Evergreen, 39-5 (2024)
Longest win streak: Evergreen, 5 (1979-present)
Current win streak: Evergreen, 5 (1979-present)
| Evergreen Victories | Shelton Victories | Tie Games |
| No. | Date | Winning Team | Losing Team | |||
| 1 | Oct. 26, 1979 | at Evergreen* | 13 | Shelton | 7 | |
| 2 | Nov. 7, 1980 | at Evergreen* | 26 | Shelton | 0 | |
| 3 | Sept. 15, 1995 | Evergreen* | 44 | at Shelton | 12 | |
| 4 | Sept. 20, 1996 | at Evergreen* | 26 | Shelton | 12 | |
| 5 | Oct. 10, 2024 | at Evergreen* | 39 | Shelton | 5 | |