Toledo Indians
First meeting: Sept. 28, 2012 - Toledo 60, Seton Catholic 13
Latest meeting: Oct. 4, 2013 - Toledo 39, Seton Catholic 22
Next meeting: TBD
Meetings total: 2
All-time series: Toledo Leads 2-0
League series: Toledo Leads 2-0
Post-season series: n/a
Largest victory: Toledo, 60-13 (2012)
Longest win streak: Toledo, 2 (2012-present)
Current win streak: Toledo, 2 (2012-present)
| Seton Catholic Victories | Toledo Victories | Tie Games |
| No. | Date | Winning Team | Losing Team | |||
| 1 | Sept. 28, 2012 | at Toledo* | 60 | Seton Catholic | 13 | |
| 2 | Oct. 4, 2013 | Toledo* | 39 | at Seton Catholic | 22 | |